I would say more like 4.5 stars. Overall, a good dive day--not colorful coral, but lots of fish and critters (several morays, a ray, a baby shark, and many starfish). It was a Discover Scuba experience for my nephew, and a Refresher dive for me. We did not have equipment with us, and it was included in the price of our dive. It was pretty much "hands-off" diving--the guides took care of all the equipment for us. I thought our guide did a great job (Lucas). I would take a half-star off for the lack of information as we checked in that morning. I was a bit confused when we were given fins, but no other equipment going to the boat. It turns out the rest was on the boat, but being a woman of a larger size, I wish I knew for sure the BCD would fit me before we got ferried out the dive boat. I booked through another shop and this was who they booked us with. I think in future I'd book directly with this dive shop rather than book through a surf school that also offered scuba.