We thoroughly enjoyed this trip, particularly because of the wonderful people who went--but the overall experience at Turquoise Bay was excellent.
Pros
> The resort experience from the shuttle, to the front desk, accommodations, food & drink, cleanliness and hospitality was top notch.
> The dive crew was professional and courteous.
> The diving was excellent and tailored to everyone's dive abilities.
> The resort was secluded. You felt as though you had the place all to yourselves.
> The overall experience felt cost effective as a traveler--we got a lot for the money we spent.
Cons
> Having to "check in" at the airport as a group was frustrating (couldn't check in prior, no digital boarding pass, couldn't get seated by spouse, etc.). It was distasteful both at the start and then again at the end of an otherwise great travel experience.
> The bug problem at Turquoise Bay was insufferable for many. It didn't seem to matter where you were on the resort (except on the boat), you were eaten alive by whatever bugs they have there. They fumigated several times, but it didn't help much.